Surgeon mistakenly removes woman’s kidney

Patients in Iowa who consent to routine surgery do not expect to wake up to find out that one of their kidneys has been removed unnecessarily. That is exactly what happened to a Florida woman who was having an anterior spinal fusion operation.

The doctor who removed the kidney spotted what he thought was a malignant growth in the woman’s pelvic region. After the organ’s removal, a pathologist discovered it was a pelvic kidney. The organ was a functional kidney besides being in an unusual location inside the woman’s body.

The woman filed a medical malpractice lawsuit against the doctor alleging that the surgeon performed a medically unnecessary procedure. She also alleged that he failed to review MRI images prior to assisting with the surgery which would have revealed the kidney’s location.

The surgeon settled the lawsuit but could still face a fine or loss of his medical license. His attorney claims that he has not acknowledged fault for the medical procedure but settled the case due to the uncertainty of litigation.

Medical malpractice can cause serious health problems and death in some cases. An attorney experienced in handling medical professional negligence cases may be able to help clients who believe that they have undergone an unnecessary procedure. There are several other types of common medical errors that cause injury and death every year such as wrong-site surgery, anesthesia errors, misdiagnosis and objects left inside patients after surgery.

The plaintiff in a medical malpractice case must prove that the medical professional committed malpractice and must demonstrate how they have been damaged as a result. An attorney may be able to assist clients determine what went wrong by examining medical records and consulting expert witnesses. An attorney may help clients prove their case in court through expert testimony, medical records and other evidence.

Free Case Evaluation

Was Your Injury Caused by Medical Negligence?

Every case is different. Speak with our attorneys directly — it’s free and confidential.

FEATURED RESULT – NOVEMBER 2025

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

$19.8M

Verdict against Mayo Clinic — among the largest medical malpractice verdicts in Iowa history

Related Posts

Medical Malpractice

How improving time outs may prevent wrong-site surgery

Every week, there are anywhere between 40 and 60 wrong-site surgeries that are performed in Iowa and the rest of the U.S. The most frequent

Medical Malpractice

Study links frequent doctor burnout with malpractice

According to a study recently published in Mayo Clinic Proceedings, more than half of all doctors in Iowa and across the U.S. suffer from burnout.

Medical Malpractice

Opioids and anticoagulants cause many drug-related claims

In recent years, an aging senior population and the increased availability of healthcare options for younger people has resulted in a growing number of Iowa

Medical Malpractice

9-year-old dies hours after tonsillectomy

Our source article for today’s blog post tells a tragic story of a nine-year-old girl who died mere hours after a routine tonsillectomy. Given that

Medical Malpractice

Understanding Medical Malpractice: When Does a Mistake Become Negligence?

We place enormous trust in our doctors, nurses, and healthcare providers. When we enter a hospital or clinic, we believe we’re in capable hands—hands guided

Medical Malpractice

Iowa clinic misdiagnoses cancer, removes prostate by mistake

Two years ago, an Iowa clinic mistakenly removed a man’s healthy prostate gland after misdiagnosing him with cancer. The case involving the 67-year-old Iowa native

Disclaimer

No Legal Advice

The information on this website is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as legal advice. You should consult a qualified attorney regarding your specific situation.

No Attorney-Client Relationship

Contacting Hixson & Brown, P.C. by phone, email, or contact form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Such a relationship is only established through a signed engagement letter.

Confidential Information

Please do not send confidential or sensitive information until an attorney-client relationship has been formally established. Information sent prior may not be protected by attorney-client privilege.

No Guarantee of Results

Every case is different. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome in your case.